Inspiration – B&O in Southern Ohio

The following youtube video shows the B&O from Chillicothe should through Jackson and other inspiring areas. The details along the track are inspiring for HAVOC even though the time frame is different. The ballast shows cinder base with lighter colors on top, very similar to the HAVOC standards.

Module Status Sept 1 2021

All through COVID we the members of HAVOC have been working on the modules. Much of the work is scenery related as most modules have have been in operation.

Paul’s skewed bridge module has a completed bridge, ballast and is sporting new trees.
Skewed bridge module just needs some water.
Don’s feed mill module has gotten land forms and ballast. Scenery will be coming soon.
Paul’s interurban crossing module. As you can see the mocked up road will be concrete. The concrete highway is putting the interurban out of business.
Tree’s are being tested on Dave’s curved cut module.
Ballast has been completed on the yard module. Chris can only setup two modules at a time in his home, so there is no way to see the whole 5 module set at once.
Chris is playing with structures to serve as the industries at the yard. Some of these may be stand ins while he hones his skills.

Indy Junction 2022?

HAVOC is proposing a road trip to the Indy Junction NMRA Super Regional. Here are a few of the track plan ideas to be sent to them. They all include the in-progress Steel Mill module. It should have all track, basic scenery, some structures and mockups of the Steel Mill by the time of the convention.

The additional of the Steel Mill will significantly enhance our operating potential. CC&WB’s are used to forward freight and TT&TO will be used during operating sessions. We hope to have some during the show.

The S “Super Man” HAVOC setup. It’s a bit bulky at 35’x30′. The public could walk around all aspects of the layout. To save space, the top or bottom could be pushed against a wall.
U-Shape at 18×45′. We like U shapes because both loops are next to each other for easy running. In a setup like this, the public could walk inside the layout. One side could be against a wall.
This pinched U shape is only 17’x45′. The public would not be allowed to walk inside the layout. This would be a bit tight for our own operation within the layout, but would make it easy to run for 1-2 people
Slightly shorter at 22×42. As drawing the public would not be allowed inside. Removing one module would open the entrance more so that the public could enter. If the public enters, than the bottom could go against a wall.
A big “L” shape. This layout is roughly 50×50′ It could go around the outside of another layout.
The I formation. At roughly 10×100′ this setup is intriguing to consider. It could wander down a wall.

All of these are potential setups for 2022. Interestingly, each of the setups takes between 800 and 1000 sqft. Possibly that means the modules can be squished into any shape of that square footage. Hopefully we’ll go to Indy Junction and see you there….Come help us run trains!

Proposed 2021 Fall NMRA Show plans

The setup we had for 2019’s fall show did not contain the skewed bridge module. So I’ve drawing up two new plans to utilize the bridge module and fit in roughly the same space.

By adding an additional curve to the bottom then the bridge, the lower loop fits into the original space without blocking the doors or human access.
This plan swaps the location of the yard and feed mill modules. A bit of a twist of the layout keeps the layout in the original space (or near so).

2019-2021 Track Plans

As the groups grows our potential track plans change. For 2019-2021 here are a few of the ways HAVOC can be setup. We hope to use one of these in for the 2021 October NMRA show.

This U shaped plan got used in the 2019 NMRA Fall Show.
Another U-shape that was a candidate for the show.
A pinched U-shape
A narrow U-shape (or is it a J or G?).
Clearly a J-shape
Opened up to a L-shape
Linear or I-shape. The curves and loops ensure the setup is stable. At nearly 65′ long, this could be hard to fit into spaces that have access doors and fire codes.

Inspiration – September Scenery

The scenery standards call for doing September scenery during the fall grain rush.  The standards call for predominantly green colored trees, only occasional orange and no red.  Yellow would be coming out.  Basically the scenery is to be just as color transition starts.  The following photos all taken within a few days in the middle of September for inspiration for our modules.  Standards or ratios can be derived from the photos as well as several other scenery hints/suggestions and outlined below.

Along Round Bottom Rd. The Peavine is to the right. Notice the light colors of the tops of the trees and grasses going starting brown. Golden Rod is present.

Round bottom east of I-275. Pevine is on along the road. Notice the various greens for the trees.

Same location as above, looking east.

The undergrowth. Includes white flowers.

Looking the the other way on the tracks

Looking across a field to a road row of trees. Notice the trees are green of various shades.   Some are very muted in color.  Few reds some trees are headed toward yellows.

Light green, yellows and just a bit of orange. This is the max color to inspire HAVOC.

Same day as above. A bit too much orange in one tree, but yellow and light greens. The tree without leaves is dead, it lost it’s leaves seasons ago.  This is absolute max ratio of color.  If all modules max at this ratio, such that orange is 1 in 30 and yellow is 1 in 7 or so, and the rest of the trees are shades of green, HAVOC will be believable and consistent across the modules.

No orange here. Light greens and hints of yellow.

 

Fields and grasses turn yellow and brown first.

More field colors.  What plants are out in the field?  Are they correct for 1923?

Grasses along the tracks of CET Railroad. Light green, yellow and going brown.

Using the above photos and observations of that week, the following guidelines and suggestions can be made.

  1. Grasses and low growth can be light green in color through yellow and even a significant amount of brown on hillsides (dry areas).
  2. Flowers of white, yellow (Golden Rod and others) and possibly some purple can be seen around.  Whole fields of Golden Rod were observed
  3. Trees are predominantly still green.  But colors are going lighter and some are quire muted.  Dark colors on bottom.  Lots of leaves are yellow some near the yellows are brown.  Very few trees have any orange and almost no Red.
    1. 75% of Trees are green only
    2. 20% have yellow and 20% of those have some minor browning around the yellow.  Yellow and Green leaves are next to each other on the tree.  A tree will be a broad range of color, not all one green.
    3. 5% have Orange.  The orange is not on the whole tree, but just if a few main branches.  Trees with Orange tend not to have much yellow, but may have brown.

The difference of HAVOC’s membership is that we embrace such standards so that all modules look like a family even if the modeling is completed by different people.

Module – Sam’s curve with road crossing

Sam, a new HAVOC participant has taken over work on two  curved models.  The first is a curved module with a road crossing.  He has made a start on the scenery.  Sam is very detail oriented and works systematically.  He hopes to have one quadrant of the module fully sceniced for the All Scales show in Salem Ohio (March 22, 2020 weekend)

HAVOC_Sam_Curve_RoadCrossing1

A closeup of the track as it approaches the future road crossing. Sam started by shaping the scenery, ballasting around the track, then adding the road. He has started to add earth, rocks and some static grass.

HAVOC_Sam_Curve_RoadCrossing2

Sam started by doing the edges of the scenery near the track and along the fascia edges. The road divides the module into four quadrants that he plans to scenic uniquely.

Rigling Mills Gets a siding

The Rigling mills module was first posted about in Grain Elevator Module.  In that post the mill design was a single track with a spur to a Grain Elevator.  As the grain elevator module progressed and we considered the other modules in the pipeline, we decided that we needed a passing siding.  Adding an additional 5 feet to Rigling mills to make it a 10 foot module would be the simplest way to achieve our objectives.

HAVOC_RiglingMills1

The original Rigling Mills section with the passing siding added to the front

HAVOC_RigglingMills2

Don getting a picture of his handy work. The Walthers grain elevator is perfect for the 1923 time frame. Like the prototypes it will be a skyscraper in it’s rural setting.

HAVOC_RigglingMills3

Don chats it up with one of the attendees to the 2019 NMRA Div-7 show. Chris is in the background watching on. The “bumpout” to the module fascia for the grain elevator can be seen at left.

HAVOC module design – Bland is exciting!

HAVOC is not just a modular group, it is instead a themed layout with a story to tell.  A major part of that story is operations and more specifically TT&TO operations.  TT&TO operation are better the more distance a layout has between towns.  The distance provides two benefits:  1) Space for trains to switch so the engine of a train is not in one town while the caboose is in another 2) Traveling distance between towns for the feeling of running.  The HAVOC team feels distance is so important we even go so far as to request module participants build equal length of single track modules as double track modules (see the participation page).  To date no one has built both types of modules, but combined HAVOC collective has to achieve the equivalent. Our most recent single track initiative is four 45 degree curved modules.  Curves were chosen to enable the setups to turn back on themselves to fit smaller spaces.

42″ Radius 45 degree module

Initially, the vision for the 4 modules was dramatic bridges and eye popping trestles inspired by an area of the PRR’s Zanesville branch east out of Morrow following Todd’s Fork a good sized creek.

HAVOC_ToddsCreek

The Zanesville branch crossed Todds Fork 5 times in two miles. A dramatic section of Ohio railroading. Showing that railroads that served rural farm communities could be dramatic.  Click to see more PRR track Charts

HAVOC_ToddsForkArial

Satellite view of a portion of the Todd Creek area today. The red dashed line is what I think was the railroad. The curvy Todd Fork is clearly seen crisscrossing the line.

In discussions with Tom Patterson, who canoed the Todds Creek in his youth (1970’s), we got the impression that the bridges were multi segment girder bridges.  The bridges were very significant and well above the water line (HAVOC members have yet to explore the area on foot)

Several design attempts were made to include one or more such bridges in the 4 curved modules.  A design was even considered where instead of independent modules, two curved sections would be used to offset the track from center and use sharper 30-36″ radius to obtain 9″ of straight track.  While 9″  might hold a bridge it just seemed too contrived.

To capture Todds Creek a different approach is required.  Rather bridges on the curve modules, put the bridges on small straight modules, say 24-36″ long, and use the curves to model the space in between the bridges.  If you look at the satellite view, there is lots of bland scenery between the bridge locations.  The bland terrain consists of road crossings, fields, trees, and the like.  Looking further east, Todds Fork is not as curvy and the distance between bridges become greater and greater meaning the ratio of pasture land to bridges increases until the bridges apart.  So a better approach capturing the essence of the PRR along Todds Creek is would be to make the curves pasture land and the and then at a future time model bridges on short trestles.

When the design for Todds Fork Creek modules stalled out, we started looking elsewhere for inspiration.  We knew the B&O Ohio Division had a few single lane underpasses.  Such an underpass would likely fit on a curved module.  Once such  scene was the Lacy Rd. underpass which became the inspiration for one of the modules.

HAVOC_LaceyRdFromNorth

B&O’s Lacy Road Under pass, looking South. This bridge is still used by I&O today.

HAVOC_LaceyRoad_FormSouth

B&O’s Lacy Rd. underpass looking North

HAVOC_LacyRd_Satellite

Satellite view of Lacey Rd. The modules are only 16″ wide, so even building will be few. The focus will be on the bridge, track and railroad right of way.

Another inspiring scene is the rural road crossing that was very common in Ohio and elsewhere in the United States.  People cross them every day.   The E.Fork Rd. crossing may be the inspiration for another of the modules.

HAVOC_EForkRd

Approach to the EFork Rd. grade crossing of the B&O (IORY) looking South.

HAVOC_EForkRd2

Southeast side of the EFork Rd grade crossing. HAVOC module builders take pleasure in the simple details of the fence, field, right of way, road and trying to image what it would have looked like in 1923. Maybe fewer trees?

HAVOC_EForkRd3

Southwest side of the EFork Rd. crossing. What would it have looked like in 1923?

Two of the curves appear in our 2019 setup at the local NMRA division show.  The scenery shaping had been started on them.  The Lacy Rd. underpass is the inspiration for one of the modules and the other is imagined as a side hill cut.  What will happen to the other two is unknown.  A new participant has offered to take them and make them his own.  We’ll see what he finds that is so bland it is exciting!

HAVOC_Curves

The earth color module is the cut module as roughed scenery and to the right of it is the underpass module. Both appeared at the 2019 NMRA Division 7 show as part of the setup. The modules to either side of them are scenery only modules too. The combination of the 5 sections is over 16 feet of running.